災(zāi)變的寓言：德里羅《墜落的人》中的敘事性與存在
發(fā)布時間：2018-08-16 15:24
【摘要】：《墜落的人》是唐·德里羅在后9·11時代對恐怖主義的一次深刻反思。該小說不單是德里羅對恐怖主義話題的再現(xiàn),更是借以后現(xiàn)代之災(zāi)難對人類存在的一次本體論探討。本文擬對《墜落的人》進(jìn)行一次海德格爾式解讀。借助于海德格爾的本體論和美學(xué)觀,輔以利科對敘事性的研究,該論文旨在探索德里羅這本后9·11小說中的敘事性和存在,即如何敘事出此在的本真存在與自我。在利科對于敘事性的研究中,他認(rèn)為所有的敘事性都是依賴時間而建立的;而海德格爾的存有論也是以時間作為存在的基礎(chǔ)。因此,本文對敘事性和存在的討論也將建立于對時間性的探討之上。本論文的主體包括兩個方面,一方面將探討個體的敘事性,另一方面則將探討藝術(shù)的敘事性。第一方面對個體敘事的探討主要借用的是創(chuàng)傷理論,正如災(zāi)難與創(chuàng)傷的雙生性決定了幸存者的存在必定要經(jīng)由敘事。因此,借助于拉卡普拉和弗洛伊德的創(chuàng)傷研究,創(chuàng)傷下的個體敘事性首先分為了抑郁敘事和哀悼敘事。由于抑郁敘事根植于過去,現(xiàn)在淪落為過去的強(qiáng)迫性重復(fù)的再演。哀悼敘事才有能力擺脫過去,重塑存在者。倘若將創(chuàng)傷視為存在的一個隱喻,《墜落的人》中的創(chuàng)傷者沉湎于過去便是一種由抑郁敘事所致的此在之被拋狀態(tài)。海德格爾認(rèn)為此在所依賴的正是一種社會文化的語境,而后現(xiàn)代的社會文化語境則是一個敘事環(huán),牢牢套住了此在于一種非本真的存在之中,亦如抑郁敘事將創(chuàng)傷者拋于過去一般。德里羅所批判的社會文化便是一種由科技的貧瘠、意識形態(tài)的元敘事和消費主義所建構(gòu)的后現(xiàn)代認(rèn)知。在其敘事環(huán)中,個體對于災(zāi)難和創(chuàng)傷的認(rèn)知是經(jīng)意識形態(tài)建構(gòu)的,他們?yōu)闅v史、教育和媒體的建構(gòu)主義所賦予的創(chuàng)傷者之政治身份迷惑,從而忽視了其本真存在和自我。因而,敘事環(huán)內(nèi)只存在抑郁敘事,哀悼則是政治之禁忌。德里羅對《墜落的人》的循環(huán)敘事結(jié)構(gòu)也反映了個體敘事的無效性。因此,此在的抑郁便是非本真存在和自我缺失的敘事性表達(dá)。由于敘事環(huán)讓個體敘事完全失效,其本真存在與自我便成了一種妄想。但德里羅在《墜落的人》中內(nèi)置的藝術(shù)卻有著一種彌賽亞式救贖之可能。因此,本文的第二大部分便對德里羅文本中的藝術(shù)敘事性進(jìn)行存有論式探討。利科將敘事主要分成兩類,一種是述事,另一種是戲劇敘事。在《墜落的人》中述事主要包括有話語敘事和畫語敘事。然而這兩種述事根本上還是一種抑郁敘事。在文本中,話語敘事主要表現(xiàn)為詩歌和一般話語,但這種述事缺乏海德格爾所謂的"詩性"和"靈性",因而無法在敘事廢墟中重構(gòu)詩意的棲所。而畫語敘事,即對莫蘭蒂靜物寫生的藝格敷詞,更是受到了意識形態(tài)的蠶食與消費主義的荼毒,畫也因而墮落為消費品而非海德格爾意義上的藝術(shù)品。因此,對于本真存在的去蔽和自我的揭示只能經(jīng)由墜落的人的行為藝術(shù)來完成。麗昂與墜落的人的三次相遇如同幕間劇,他的冒險一躍成就是一種戲劇敘事,而這種戲劇敘事則組成了一場文本內(nèi)的哀悼劇。借鑒本雅明對哀悼劇的研究,本論文認(rèn)為《墜落的人》中行為藝術(shù)家的戲劇敘事正是一種哀悼劇的藝術(shù)。這種真正藝術(shù)的敘事性不僅超越了敘事環(huán),它本身還是一種哀悼敘事。墜落的人的戲劇敘事不僅走出了創(chuàng)傷,還對此在本真存在和自我進(jìn)行了去蔽。德里羅通過《墜落的人》中藝術(shù)的敘事性將小說化為一種藝術(shù)寓言,從而揭示了真正藝術(shù)對于此在本真存在和自我的救贖。
[Abstract]:"Falling Man" is a profound reflection on terrorism by Don Delillo in the post-9/11 era. This novel is not only Delillo's reappearance of the topic of terrorism, but also an ontological exploration of human existence through the disaster of post-modern times. This paper intends to make a Heidegger-style interpretation of "Falling Man". The thesis aims at exploring the narrative and existence in Dererot's later 9/11 novels, that is, how to narrate the real existence and the self of being. Therefore, the discussion of narrativeness and existence in this paper will also be based on the discussion of timeliness. The main body of this paper includes two aspects: one is to explore the narrativeness of individuals, the other is to explore the narrativeness of art. Trauma theory, just as the twin nature of disaster and trauma determines that survivors must exist through narrative. Therefore, with the help of Lakapra and Freud's trauma studies, Individual Narrative under trauma is divided into depressive narrative and mournful narrative. Mourning narrative is the ability to get rid of the past and reshape the existence. If trauma is regarded as a metaphor of existence, the traumatist's indulgence in the past is a state of being thrown away by depressed narrative. Heidegger believes that this is based on a social and cultural context, and the post-modern society. The cultural context is a narrative ring, which is firmly held in a kind of non-real existence, as depressed narrative throws the wounded into the past. The social culture criticized by Dererot is a kind of post-modern cognition constructed by the barren science and technology, ideological meta-narrative and consumerism. Cognition of disaster and trauma is ideologically constructed. They confuse the political identity of the wounded given by the constructivism of history, education and media, thus ignoring their true existence and self. Constructions also reflect the ineffectiveness of individual narratives. Therefore, the depression of Being is the narrative expression of non-real existence and self-absence. Because narrative rings completely invalidate individual narratives, their true existence and self become a delusion. But Delillo's art in The Falling Man has a possibility of Messianic redemption. The second part of this paper is an existential discussion of the artistic narratives in Delillo's text. Rico divides narratives into two main categories, one is narrative, the other is dramatic narrative. In Falling Man, narratives mainly include discourse narrative and pictorial narrative. In the text, discourse narrative is mainly expressed in poetry and general discourse, but this kind of narrative lacks Heidegger's so-called "poetic" and "spiritual" so that it can not reconstruct poetic habitat in the narrative ruins. Therefore, the deconstruction and self-disclosure of the real being can only be accomplished through the behavioral art of the fallen man. The three encounters between Leon and the fallen man are like a curtain play. His leap of adventure is a kind of dramatic narrative, and this kind of dramatic narrative constitutes a kind of dramatic narrative. Drawing lessons from Benjamin's study of mourning drama, this paper holds that the dramatic narrative of the behavioral artist in The Falling Man is just the art of mourning drama. The narrative of this real art is not only beyond the narrative ring, but also a kind of mourning narrative itself. The dramatic narrative of the falling man is not only out of the trauma, but also right. Delillo transforms the novel into an artistic fable through the narrative of art in Falling Man, thus revealing the true art's redemption of this real being and self.
【學(xué)位授予單位】：南京大學(xué)
【學(xué)位級別】：碩士
【學(xué)位授予年份】：2017
【分類號】：I712.074
[Abstract]:"Falling Man" is a profound reflection on terrorism by Don Delillo in the post-9/11 era. This novel is not only Delillo's reappearance of the topic of terrorism, but also an ontological exploration of human existence through the disaster of post-modern times. This paper intends to make a Heidegger-style interpretation of "Falling Man". The thesis aims at exploring the narrative and existence in Dererot's later 9/11 novels, that is, how to narrate the real existence and the self of being. Therefore, the discussion of narrativeness and existence in this paper will also be based on the discussion of timeliness. The main body of this paper includes two aspects: one is to explore the narrativeness of individuals, the other is to explore the narrativeness of art. Trauma theory, just as the twin nature of disaster and trauma determines that survivors must exist through narrative. Therefore, with the help of Lakapra and Freud's trauma studies, Individual Narrative under trauma is divided into depressive narrative and mournful narrative. Mourning narrative is the ability to get rid of the past and reshape the existence. If trauma is regarded as a metaphor of existence, the traumatist's indulgence in the past is a state of being thrown away by depressed narrative. Heidegger believes that this is based on a social and cultural context, and the post-modern society. The cultural context is a narrative ring, which is firmly held in a kind of non-real existence, as depressed narrative throws the wounded into the past. The social culture criticized by Dererot is a kind of post-modern cognition constructed by the barren science and technology, ideological meta-narrative and consumerism. Cognition of disaster and trauma is ideologically constructed. They confuse the political identity of the wounded given by the constructivism of history, education and media, thus ignoring their true existence and self. Constructions also reflect the ineffectiveness of individual narratives. Therefore, the depression of Being is the narrative expression of non-real existence and self-absence. Because narrative rings completely invalidate individual narratives, their true existence and self become a delusion. But Delillo's art in The Falling Man has a possibility of Messianic redemption. The second part of this paper is an existential discussion of the artistic narratives in Delillo's text. Rico divides narratives into two main categories, one is narrative, the other is dramatic narrative. In Falling Man, narratives mainly include discourse narrative and pictorial narrative. In the text, discourse narrative is mainly expressed in poetry and general discourse, but this kind of narrative lacks Heidegger's so-called "poetic" and "spiritual" so that it can not reconstruct poetic habitat in the narrative ruins. Therefore, the deconstruction and self-disclosure of the real being can only be accomplished through the behavioral art of the fallen man. The three encounters between Leon and the fallen man are like a curtain play. His leap of adventure is a kind of dramatic narrative, and this kind of dramatic narrative constitutes a kind of dramatic narrative. Drawing lessons from Benjamin's study of mourning drama, this paper holds that the dramatic narrative of the behavioral artist in The Falling Man is just the art of mourning drama. The narrative of this real art is not only beyond the narrative ring, but also a kind of mourning narrative itself. The dramatic narrative of the falling man is not only out of the trauma, but also right. Delillo transforms the novel into an artistic fable through the narrative of art in Falling Man, thus revealing the true art's redemption of this real being and self.
【學(xué)位授予單位】：南京大學(xué)
【學(xué)位級別】：碩士
【學(xué)位授予年份】：2017
【分類號】：I712.074
【相似文獻(xiàn)】
相關(guān)期刊論文 前10條
1 張華;;美麗混亂中的重新敘述——重論1980年代中后期先鋒詩歌敘事性問題[J];佳木斯大學(xué)社會科學(xué)學(xué)報;2008年02期
2 郭軼卿;許并生;;宋代敘事性詩歌的現(xiàn)實性[J];山西大同大學(xué)學(xué)報(社會科學(xué)版);2010年01期
3 付磊;賀嘉;;敘事性舞蹈在音樂劇《西區(qū)故事》中的功能[J];北京舞蹈學(xué)院學(xué)報;2014年04期
4 張先;場與流(一)——關(guān)于戲劇的敘事性問題[J];戲劇;2001年02期
5 張先;場與流(二)——關(guān)于戲劇的敘事性問題[J];戲劇;2001年03期
6 錢文亮;1990年代詩歌中的敘事性問題[J];文藝爭鳴;2002年06期
7 康建強(qiáng);;詞的敘事性原因探析[J];齊齊哈爾大學(xué)學(xué)報(哲學(xué)社會科學(xué)版);2006年01期
8 傅華;;開放寫作的書寫態(tài)勢和形式表征——論20世紀(jì)90年代詩歌中的敘事性書寫[J];西華師范大學(xué)學(xué)報(哲學(xué)社會科學(xué)版);2009年02期
9 聞慧蓮;;探究舞蹈電影的主題表現(xiàn)與敘事性[J];電影文學(xué);2009年21期
10 尚必武;;西方文論關(guān)鍵詞 敘事性[J];外國文學(xué);2010年06期
相關(guān)會議論文 前6條
1 楊亮;;“敘事性”最初先行者——張曙光[A];“中生代與新世紀(jì)詩壇的新格局——兩岸四地第五屆當(dāng)代詩學(xué)論壇”論文集[C];2013年
2 龍揚(yáng)志;;敘事性·生命體驗·詩意生成——讀李小洛組詩《孤獨書》[A];首都師范大學(xué)駐校詩人李小洛詩歌創(chuàng)作研討會論文集[C];2007年
3 王祥兵;穆雷;;學(xué)術(shù)著作翻譯的理想模式——以趙文靜中譯本《翻譯與沖突:敘事性闡釋》為例[A];中國翻譯學(xué)學(xué)科建設(shè)高層論壇摘要[C];2013年
4 張同鑄;;《論“敘事性意境”及其建構(gòu)》論文梗概[A];2009江蘇省美學(xué)學(xué)會年會“當(dāng)代審美文化與藝術(shù)傳統(tǒng)”學(xué)術(shù)研討會會議論文集[C];2009年
5 張同鑄;;論“敘事性意境”及其建構(gòu)[A];新世紀(jì)美學(xué)與藝術(shù)——江蘇省美學(xué)學(xué)會第七屆會員大會暨學(xué)術(shù)研討會論文集[C];2011年
6 徐s，
本文編號：2186387
本文鏈接：http://www.sikaile.net/xiandaiwenxuelunwen/2186387.html
教材專著
