公共利益的界定及立法表達
發(fā)布時間:2018-10-14 10:46
【摘要】: 法的功能之一在于能夠給人們提供一種預期,這就需要法律必須具有相對的穩(wěn)定性和確定性。法律概念作為構成法的基本要素之一,其內涵與外延的確定與否直接影響著涉及此概念的法律規(guī)范能否按立法者的意志和精神很好的貫徹執(zhí)行從而形成一種明確的預期,真正地起到規(guī)范公民行為、調控社會矛盾的作用。由于憲法上對公共利益的明確規(guī)定,公共利益已然成為我國法律體系中的一個重要概念。但由于目前的法律規(guī)范和司法解釋沒有對公共利益作出絲毫的界定和解釋,學界也沒有一個統(tǒng)一的認識,這在某種程度上導致了公共利益的虛化;而與此相對應的則是公共利益在社會中的廣泛使用,其內涵和外延被無限擴張,公共利益與私人利益、政府利益等模糊難辯,導致了公共利益的泛化。因此,對于這樣一個社會生活語境和法律語境都非常重要的概念必須作出一個基本的界定,明確其內涵和外延。 本文在寫作的過程中通過語義分析、比較研究和歷史研究的方法對公共利益的界定主要從以下幾個方面來展開: 第一部分主要論述公共利益作為重要的法律概念進行界定的必要性和可行性。第二部分主要從主體和內容兩個方面對公共利益的受益主體和利益內容進行詳盡的法理分析,在此基礎上將公共利益界定為具有開放性的共同體所享有的表現(xiàn)為公共產品、公共服務和公共權利等為內容的好處。第三部分重點闡述公共利益的主要特征公共性、非盈利性、客觀實在性、發(fā)展性以及層次性。第四部分運用比較分析的方法對公共利益與相關利益進行辨析,尤其是對公共利益與個人利益、公共利益與國家利益進行祥盡的辨析。第五部分主要論述公共利益界定理論的立法表達。從我國的實際情況來看,中央權力機關即全國人大及其常委會通過立法的方式對公共利益進行界定最符合中國現(xiàn)行權力體制也是最可行的。立法不僅要通過概括加列舉的方式對公共利益的內涵和外延作出界定,同時還要規(guī)定認定主體及程序,公共利益與相關利益發(fā)生沖突時的處理原則以及當公共利益侵害個人利益或者公共利益受損時的救濟途徑。
[Abstract]:One of the functions of law is to provide people with an expectation, which requires the relative stability and certainty of law. As one of the basic elements of the constitution law, the determination of the connotation and extension of the legal concept directly affects whether the legal norms involved in this concept can be carried out according to the will and spirit of the legislator, thus forming a clear expectation. Truly play a role in regulating civil behavior and regulating social contradictions. Public interest has become an important concept in the legal system of our country because of the explicit stipulation of the public interest in the constitution. However, the current legal norms and judicial interpretations do not make the slightest definition and interpretation of the public interest, and the academic community does not have a unified understanding, which to some extent led to the public interest of the virtual; The corresponding is the widespread use of public interest in society, its connotation and extension is infinitely expanded, the public interest and private interest, government interest and so on vague and indisputable, resulting in the generalization of public interest. Therefore, for such a social life context and legal context are very important concepts must make a basic definition, clear its connotation and extension. Through semantic analysis in the process of writing, The definition of public interest is mainly carried out from the following aspects: the first part mainly discusses the necessity and feasibility of defining public interest as an important legal concept. The second part mainly from the main body and the content two aspects carries on the detailed legal theory analysis to the benefit subject and the benefit content of the public interest, and on this basis defines the public interest as the public goods which the open community enjoys. The benefits of public services and public rights, etc. The third part focuses on the main characteristics of public interest, public, non-profit, objective reality, development and hierarchy. The fourth part uses the comparative analysis method to distinguish the public interest and the related interest, especially to the public interest and the personal interest, the public interest and the national interest. The fifth part mainly discusses the legislative expression of the public interest definition theory. From the actual situation of our country, it is most feasible for the central power organ, the NPC and its standing committee, to define the public interest by way of legislation, which is in line with the current power system of China. Legislation should not only define the connotation and extension of public interest by means of summing up and enumerating, but also stipulate the subject and procedure of identification. The principle of dealing with the conflict between public interest and related interest and the remedy way when public interest infringes on individual interest or public interest is damaged.
【學位授予單位】:西北師范大學
【學位級別】:碩士
【學位授予年份】:2009
【分類號】:D90
本文編號:2270216
[Abstract]:One of the functions of law is to provide people with an expectation, which requires the relative stability and certainty of law. As one of the basic elements of the constitution law, the determination of the connotation and extension of the legal concept directly affects whether the legal norms involved in this concept can be carried out according to the will and spirit of the legislator, thus forming a clear expectation. Truly play a role in regulating civil behavior and regulating social contradictions. Public interest has become an important concept in the legal system of our country because of the explicit stipulation of the public interest in the constitution. However, the current legal norms and judicial interpretations do not make the slightest definition and interpretation of the public interest, and the academic community does not have a unified understanding, which to some extent led to the public interest of the virtual; The corresponding is the widespread use of public interest in society, its connotation and extension is infinitely expanded, the public interest and private interest, government interest and so on vague and indisputable, resulting in the generalization of public interest. Therefore, for such a social life context and legal context are very important concepts must make a basic definition, clear its connotation and extension. Through semantic analysis in the process of writing, The definition of public interest is mainly carried out from the following aspects: the first part mainly discusses the necessity and feasibility of defining public interest as an important legal concept. The second part mainly from the main body and the content two aspects carries on the detailed legal theory analysis to the benefit subject and the benefit content of the public interest, and on this basis defines the public interest as the public goods which the open community enjoys. The benefits of public services and public rights, etc. The third part focuses on the main characteristics of public interest, public, non-profit, objective reality, development and hierarchy. The fourth part uses the comparative analysis method to distinguish the public interest and the related interest, especially to the public interest and the personal interest, the public interest and the national interest. The fifth part mainly discusses the legislative expression of the public interest definition theory. From the actual situation of our country, it is most feasible for the central power organ, the NPC and its standing committee, to define the public interest by way of legislation, which is in line with the current power system of China. Legislation should not only define the connotation and extension of public interest by means of summing up and enumerating, but also stipulate the subject and procedure of identification. The principle of dealing with the conflict between public interest and related interest and the remedy way when public interest infringes on individual interest or public interest is damaged.
【學位授予單位】:西北師范大學
【學位級別】:碩士
【學位授予年份】:2009
【分類號】:D90
【引證文獻】
相關碩士學位論文 前2條
1 鄭培筠;論我國城市房屋征收制度中公共利益的界定[D];復旦大學;2011年
2 陳佳麗;論立法中公共利益與私人利益的平衡[D];華東政法大學;2011年
,本文編號:2270216
本文鏈接:http://www.sikaile.net/falvlunwen/fashilw/2270216.html